
Yesterday the TV interviewed Dr Abraham Marcus Klinberg, the vice director of the Ness Ziona Biology Institute, who was convicted of heading a spy ring for the Soviet Union. He is 95 years old and very alert. He explained that all his family was killed in the Warsaw Ghetto and he escaped to the Soviet Union, that was the only country in the world that opened its borders to Jewish refugees. In Russia he was treated very well, given the opportunity to study and to have a professional career. After the war, he returned to Poland to build Socialism, but apparently it didn't work out and he ended in Israel. Here he made a nice career, heading a Department in the University of Tel Aviv and doing research in the secret Ness Ziona institute. He loved much his wife Wanda, a blond and tough Jewish girl who survived passing as Polish in the Arian side of Warsaw. His best friend in Israel was another Polish biologist, they were neighbors, who apparently managed a secret affair with Wanda.
I know very intimately the kind of person and kind of atmosphere the case took place. Tahal in its beginning was the same, a few inflated "scientists" and "professors", idolized by everybody. It cannot be imagined today the position "science" and "scientists" had in East European Jewish minds. They were bona fide scientists, but had the highest social position. Like in the Soviet Union. And they were all communists or pro-soviet. In those times it was awkward for an European Jew to be ideologically anti-soviet, because only the Soviet Union were openly, ideologically fighting antisemitism. The fact is that when asked, Klinberg openly informed them what they were doing and even gave them a culture of something. In the interview, asked why he did it, he said that those were the days of the Cold War, and he wanted the Soviet Union to have the same as the other side had. He said that Israel did never suffered any harm from what he did and I sincerely believe that he would not have harmed Israel. And that did not.
Now all these took place in the late fifties or early sixties. What were they doing in the Institute? According to open scientific publications Klinberg was working on rickettsias, mostly in typhus. In Israel there were thousands of people carrying the virus, because the Nazi camps had had terrible typhus epidemics. Anna Frank and her sister, as well my grandmother Ilona Lowy died of typhus.

Epidemic typhus is caused by
Rickettsia prowazekii. Humans are the natural reservoir for R. prowazekii, which is prevalent worldwide and transmitted by body lice when louse feces are scratched or rubbed into bite or other wounds (and sometimes the mucous membranes of the eyes or mouth). Louse infestation is usually obvious and strongly suggests typhus in the proper setting. Lice can easily eliminated by dusting infested people with DDT, malathion or lindane. But all these are insecticides that did not exist then. Klinberg's publication deals with recurring typhus, a disease that must have been quite common in Israel and that must have been very worrying for everybody. The secret work
probably also dealt with typhus, a disease that in those times and in Israel, must have been - in the minds of these people - extremely important and dangerous. The Institute has many patents and US Patent 5411992 registers the use of terpenoids as lice repellents. Typhus as a biological weapon seems to me a poor choice, as it is transmitted by louse, that requires very poor sanitary conditions to thrive. Typhus, we now know, is a concentration camp or jail disease. I don't think they succeeded in making any effective weapon at all. Klinberg, in the interview, was provoked by the journalist who said:
Imagine a person on a boat in the sea facing Tel Aviv, that opens a small box and a fine dust is carried by the wind to the city .... and Klinberg, 95 years old, replied in strongly Yiddish accented Hebrew, which we don't hear anymore in Israel, with theatrical earnestness: "I know the story, everybody will die, no, not only in Tel Aviv, but in all Israel...Don't you see that that is impossible, things do not work like that, that if there was something like that we would be all dead a long time ago...". He has a sense of humor, incredible for his age.
Now say that they did not develop any terrible biological weapon, as I think they did not, why the fantastic secret and trying to silence him? What is his real secret? Recently there was a public outcry because some soldiers who "volunteered" for an anti-anthrax injection before the Saddam Hussein war, now are suffering from side effects such as skin spots and other diseases. The Army explained that Israel was about to be attacked with anthrax (that was the disinformation coming from America) and that the American soldiers have been all injected with the same thing. But the press interviewed some former subjects of the experiment, and they were in terrible health situation, not faking it to extract money from the Army as could be assumed, and told about their "volunteering" and how the experiment was conducted. In a word, I can imagine that the terrible secret Dr. Klinberg is forced to hide is that in that time the Institute made experiment on typhus on human beings, Jews for sure, and that many had died. I can well imagine that that is what happened, because the same thing was being done in the Soviet Union and even in America, when a group of soldiers were subjected to the effects of an atomic bomb, to test how their fighting capacity would be affected. They never were told and many died of radiation-related diseases. But Russia and America are strong countries, Israel cannot afford a scandal of that proportion. Of course I have not even a fact to base this hypothesis, it is all my sick imagination. Let accept the official version, that the Institute developed some terrible biological weapon, that Klinberg delivered to the Soviets, and the revelation of what is that virus or rickettsia or whatever, would cause an irreversible damage to Israel. Truth is that I don't know and don't really care. The generation that created Israel has mostly died out, what they did, they did, and it was all for the good of the people as they understood it. I, for one Jew, forgive him and his collegues. I dont like their arrogance, but it hides insecurity and fear. Let them die in their beds and let them rest in peace and silence.
The photo taken after the liberation of the camp by British forces shows a Mass Grave in the Bergen-Belsen camp, filled mainly with inmates who had succumbed to a typhus epidemic shortly before the end of World War II or thereafter. Post Scriptum: Today's HaAretz brings another interview with a 100 years old scientist, the first director of the Nes Ziona Institute, who actually brought Klinberg into the place. He names names but they are all long dead scientists whose name says nothing to me. He says that the Institute was part of the Ministry of Science. The existence of a Ministry confirms the divine status scientists had in those times in Israel. He says Klinberg was no scientist but and administrative assistant, and the little work he did was in polio vaccine. The Institute's first mission was to develope the vaccine (that was before Salk did it). If so, they were working on polio virus, and the terrible secret of Klinberg may be unrelated to typhus. What can it be? It is known that the first mass polio immunizations in Israel failed, that is, they tried different vaccines and a large area near Hadera got a bad vaccine and many children got the disease. From July 31 to September 28, 1988, 16 persons in Israel (population 4.6 million) were reported with confirmed or suspected paralytic poliomyelitis. Thirteen cases were reported from the District of Hadera (population 180,000), located approximately 30 miles northeast of Tel Aviv. Israel began vaccination against polio with inactivated polio vaccine (IPV) in 1957. In the early 1960s, oral polio vaccine (OPV) replaced IPV nationwide. Hadera had reported the highest incidence of paralytic polio before 1982. The Ministry of Health reported in 1988 that the Hadera area received a Dutch batch and that is the reason for the failure. No one was guilty. In 1988 I was starting in the sewage business and living virus was found in the sewage. Dr Yair Folkman wrote an article saying that polio does not survive in sewage and there is no danger in sewage infected floodings. It may well be that Klinberg's secret is somehow related to this botched mass vaccination. Who knows? I dont know and it has no importance. Let sleeping dogs sleep.