I have nothing against this line of thought, except two points: (One) Instead of organizing Whites, as he says is his purpose, he is obsessing with Jews and writing book after book on the Jews. Objectively, I feel, more than White Nationalist he is Antisemite. (Second) I do agree that in certain situations Whites are oppressed and need a self-defense ethnic organization - I am thinking on the Bruderband of the South African Boers - the objective position of the White people in the world is excellent. Superb. Rather than being oppressed, they are the richest and most powerful people and nations. If they are currently losing population, it is not because a powerful enemy is killing them, or a tyrannic Pharaon is forbidding them to have children, no, they themselves are choosing to prolong their worriless youth to middle age, instead of settling down and creating families as their grandfathers were expected to do and actually did. And the economic weight of all social security and privileges to the underclass is very low, less than 1 - 2 % of the American GNP, and if look at the numbers, the underclass is NOT exploiting the middle class, but very much the opposite. In the same train of ideas, one right wing person in Israel argued that the Arab minority was living off Social Security and it was a tremendous burden on us middle class Israelis. I checked the budget and showed him that all social security payments in Israel are less than 1% of the GNP and most probably, the Arab minority, poor as it is, far from being an economic burden, is pulling his weight. Unfortunately, he stopped talking to me. And the "invasion" of the inferior races in White homelands, that so bothers MacDonald and his fellow travellers, it is not an "invasion" in the traditional sense of a fighting tribe occupying the territory of a weaker tribe, but fun-loving and lazy Europeans importing servants to their homes and then resenting them for just being there slaving for them. Even Supreme Court Judges were found employing Dominican illegal domestic servants, and then blaming her faithful employee. It is difficult to imagine a more disgusting argument against one's fellow human being.
There is also a right-wing PC mentality too, no less idiotic than the leftist PC that sacked Prof. Summers from Harvard and Nobel Prize Winner Wilson for his own institute. While I respect Prof. MacDonald's intelligence and culture, and I would like him to be honest with himself and write:
"I want America return to be what it was in 1800, when it was a pure Anglosaxon society. I want a Puritan New England Republic. Unfortunately we made a mistake and started admitting Italians, Greeks, Jews, and now we cannot stop them coming - Asians, Indians, Mexicans, you name it. Now we even lost control of our Negroes. I want to start it all once again."Should he write something like that, I could agree with him and enjoy his books. He is not the only one thinking that the past was purer, better than the present and the future. I dont think history is reversible, and being the sex obsessed anthropoids we are, miscegenation is all but unstoppable. We in Israel have gathered some experience in renewing a nation, with its deceptions and hopes, and could comment it with him. But no, MacDonald wakes with Jews in his mind, goes to through the day with Jews in his mind, and then goes to sleep dreaming with Jews. He writes only about us Jews and how bad we are. For me, then, he is a miserable, low class, sick, racist outcast. A man who slanders and incites against other human races he shares the Earth with.