Monday, October 31, 2011

Numerus Clausus in Hungary

The Numerus Clausus ("Limited Number") decree in Hungary in the twenties (almost a hundred years ago) is now a subject of academic research. The idea of the decree was to restore a middle class existence to the ethnic Hungarian lower middle class, that had lost their public service positions due to the contraction of the country after WWI (Hungary fought on the losing side and it was dismembered). This declassé people were forming fascist parties, threatening the stability of the liberal government, so they had to be catered to. Jews were thrown out of the universities (as teachers and students), from the civil service, from middle class professions (like law). Something new for me: the Numerus Clausus excluded Jews but also women: they had to make place for males.

May be this was the reason why in Hungary the fascists never seized power as they did in nearby Germany. Only under German occupation these right wing political movements finally formed a government, and then only to carry out German orders. There is an endless world of "what if...?" My Grandfather in Jaszbereny believed that the Bishop of Szolnok will protect them, the Jewish Organization urged to be quiet and become invisible, it is quite possible that their calculations were reasonable, that the Red Army was very near and one million Jews dispersed all over Hungary cannot be killed so fast. They may have estimated that the most probable outcome was that WWII would end with the mass of Hungarian Jews surviving. But one man, Adolf Eichmann, made the difference. With satanic organizational skill, with no manpower nor formal powers, he packed one million Jews into the ghettoes and transported them to Auschwitz. The war had been lost, he didnt have to do it. My entire life I dream of the warm family of uncles and many cousins that I never had.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

What might have been - the saddest words of all.

The Jews had always survived anti-Semitism in the past by hunkering down, making a deal, paying ransom, etc. Until the Final Solution was formulated, it was thought (even by the anti-Semites themselves) that what they wanted was for the Jews to be made so miserable that they would get the hint and leave the country, not that they should all be murdered. This was so unprecedented that the Jews couldn't believe it, even after the hints became ample - only in retrospect is it believable.

K

J said...

The saddest of all is that in the case of Hunary, it worked till August 1944. On January, Hungary was liberated by the Red Army.

Anonymous said...

Before you go all misty-eyed over the Red Army, remember that J Stalin having determined that he was going to win the war on his terms decided to linger and clear out the resistance of the right-wing in all of Eastern Europe. He could very well have used the services of the Polish resistance to clear out the Germans but satanic strategist that he was, he chose to let them die instead. When you think about it, which leader ensured that the Polish Jews would have nowhere to run after the Nazi-Soviet Pact? Which man had through his criminal acts destroyed the ability of the Russian Army to mount an effective defence? And having done all this, emerge at the end of the war as the mightiest dictator the world has ever seen? It is the kind of thing that makes one doubt the existence of a just and powerful God.

Ivan

Anonymous said...

I don't think that J was praising the Red Army - just stating a fact - that the Jews of Hungary were killed in a brief window - a few more months and they would have made it thru the war alive.


K